Maladaptation and the Shadow of Inadequacy
   

Maladaptation and the Shadow of Inadequacy

Most of us have been on the receiving end of something we couldn’t put a name to in real time.

It could be that collaborator retelling a story with themselves at the centre of it, or the friend whose compliments arrive with corrections attached. It might be a family member who introduces us at gatherings with names we stopped being decades ago, or the team member who steers every ‘shared’ decision back towards their own needs. It might be an intimate relationship where every conversation leaves you feeling like you just apologised for something you’re not sure you understand. Or, on a broader scale, it might be a specific cultural environment you’re navigating due to relocation, a Third Culture upbringing, or a vocation where navigating all of these comes with the job.

Each instance on its own is easy to brush off.

Repeated often enough, though, they begin to form a shape that a part of us will feel but not necessarily see clearly. And without the right language to identify it, the default is usually self-doubt.

“Am I overreacting? Is it me?”

This post is an attempt to offer some insight into the growth of that language. It’s based on a personal journal entry written during an (ongoing) phase of my life in which I find myself hungry for a deeper understanding of the human psyche, as I navigate a somewhat intense period involving grief, one of the most disturbing racial attacks I have faced in my life (one that even growing up amidst some of the most apparently unrelated cultures didn’t prepare me for), and a career in an industry that leaves its participants frozen and overwhelmed by unprecedented levels of uncertainty, and in which all the factors described so far play a role.

When I journaled, I wanted to do more than just share. I wanted to use all the study I have put the hours into these past few years: psychology, yoga, movement arts, neuroscience, even entrepreneurship, in addition to a 30-year full-time practice as a professional musician. All of which pushed me to take a minute and explore where these patterns might stem from, why they persist, and how I can hold compassion for the situations enacting them without taking on uncalled-for weight as my own, but also without reaching for oversimplified theories that use cultural or political differences as a blanket statement.

The writing might come across as a bit more unorthodox in comparison to some of the other articles I’ve written, since these were rather fresh events I was processing and then ‘rewrote’ into something that might be helpful to others going through something similar.

Where it begins

A thought before going anywhere with this.

It is imperative, in my experience, to distinguish something here. One person’s need to assert dominance is not the other person’s burden to bear. This could be interpreted through both an individual and a collective lens, where ‘person’ is replaced by ‘group’.

That being said, the burden being referred to is one that deserves to be looked at with curiosity and, more pertinently, compassion.

Yes, you read that right. Compassion. Even for the obnoxious kinds of encounters that threaten, at the very least, to exhaust us with their persistence and shock us with their tastelessness, and at most, to cost us our well-being and safety on multiple levels of that word.

It traces itself back to a past, usually the most formative stages of a person’s life, when a human being is dependent on others for their safety in every sense of the word. Usually on a caregiver. Almost always, really.

Think of childhood experiences in which the caregiver is (often unwittingly) demanding more of a child than the child is actually equipped to offer, as proof of what later equates to their ‘worthiness’. And the exchange involved is for safety at its most basic level: survival, food, shelter and well-being, both mental and physical.

Once it has been established as ‘family law’ that this transaction is a tenet of the relationship, the child’s options for securing that basic need are swiftly restricted to one.

Adapt. Or, to be more accurate, maladapt.

As innocent as that might sound on the surface, what this leads to is a range of behavioural patterns that begin to shape those formative years, to the point where the need to compensate for a sense of inadequacy created externally by the caregiver, when unaddressed, starts to calcify into a personality trait for the child who participated in that environment without explicit consent, until the trait becomes a system to ‘deal’ with a situation they were never supposed to be dealing with in the first place.

Still tracking?

The skills we forget to put down

What now starts to develop are maladapted skillsets.

These can take many forms.

People pleasing is perhaps the most familiar: a child who learnt that safety depended on keeping a caregiver content grows into an adult who reads the room before checking in with themselves, and says yes long before knowing whether they mean it.

Hypervigilance is its close relative, the constant scanning for shifts in mood or tone that once served as an early warning system. Perfectionism and chronic overachievement often grow from the same soil, where being good enough was conditional and approval had to be earned all over again every day.

Further along the spectrum sit the strategies that are harder to look at. ‘Manipulative’ tendencies can begin with a child learning that asking directly for what they needed was unsafe or futile, so needs had to be met by indirect means instead.

Gaslighting can grow out of an early lesson that the version of events that wins is the one that keeps you safe, until rewriting reality becomes a reflex rather than a choice. Control, and the need to dominate that this post opened with, very often traces back to a time when the person had none. And then there are the less visible retreats: emotional numbing, withdrawal, or a fierce self-reliance that refuses help because help once came at a price.

Understanding where these patterns come from does not excuse the consequences involved, but it does make them far easier to recognise, in others and in ourselves.

Each of these began as a survival skill in childhood.

What looked like an innocent, even endearing, quirk in a child takes on a darker shade once it travels into adulthood without the appropriate guidance.

And that transfer happens insidiously.

The child had no choice in the matter. The adult does, and that agency, the capacity to ensure, assert and fend for their own safety, is the one thing that truly separates the two.

Yet because the skills never ‘announce’ their arrival in adulthood, and without the appropriate work, the adult rarely realises that the choice is now theirs to make. So they simply carry on running in the background, unexamined, like the residue of software designed for a completely different operating system.

Over time, the pleasing, the scanning and the rewriting of events settle in so deeply that they come to feel like ‘just who they are’. Their identity. And what we no longer notice, we never think to question, so it carries on doing its work on everyone around it, the adult included, like malware that never got cleaned up.

That is, if the adult even reaches a point of being aware of this agency in the first place, which sadly is not a given and is often not the case. It is an intricate part of the adulthood process, and caregivers are rarely equipped, trained or inclined to support a young person through that transition, for reasons that span an incredibly diverse range of circumstances that can range from cultural to socio-economic to geopolitical factors.

The end result, in a worst-case scenario, is an inherently maladaptive personality in the offspring, who is now (and this is the darker aspect of it) potentially at risk of becoming addicted to the familiarity of danger as a foundational reality.

The subconscious mind is a lot more powerful than it gets credit for, and it will go to great lengths to justify or even seek out environments and circumstances that confirm what is essentially a bias, and in some extreme cases might even attempt to skew circumstances to fit that world view. Where someone sits on that spectrum tends to relate to the degree of trauma, or adversity as I prefer to call it, that they have had to deal with as a child.

Add the neurobiological dimension and there is a deep rabbit hole to go down. The chemicals and hormones released in the body during fight, flight or freeze can actually become something the system comes to crave. And so it goes, a vicious cycle of pain and distress.

Where does this end?

This is the question I hear increasingly often of late.

Usually when things get so bad that the child in an adult’s body is left with two options: to break, or to dissolve the patterns.

I wrote an article on this some time back, with a more specific angle regarding my coaching practice and my own experiences with therapy, which you can read here.

But for the purposes of the approach I’m taking today, I’ll go with a broader (but not superficial) take.

The constraints that stem from years of maladaptation (not ‘good enough’, ‘tall enough’, ‘smart enough’, ‘rich enough’, ‘reliable enough’, ‘attractive enough’, ‘assertive enough’ etc. etc.), will eventually become the kind of inner dialogue that tends to get louder with time. As much as I am a vehement opponent of ageism, given that my own trajectory is a direct challenge to it, in this case there is a direct correlation. Left unaddressed, that insidious voice whispering myriad versions of the above examples of ‘not enough’ will get louder.

And then, at some point, the environment in which the listener moves starts to challenge it with a remarkably similar set of patterns, confronting it with an unassuming form of resistance.

This is the kind of resistance that will usually come from external circumstances and other people, whether old friends, members of the family or, most commonly, intimate partners who have healed to an extent where such patterns are given no space in their lives. And as a last resort, these circumstances, factors and people can lead to the dark night of the soul, as they may show no hesitation in throwing the baby out with the bathwater if it comes to that.

Get it?

Hence the age-old cliché of the worst break-ups, illnesses, identity crises or career pivots as precursors to transformation and healing. It might be the tritest of patterns, but the pertinence is too striking to dismiss as mere coincidence.

The child who was never protected

Where the early adversity is significant, something else tends to happen too, in the way it manifests in adult life.

It gets complex. It’s not uncommon for a child who has been harmed, or made to feel unsafe as a base reality throughout their childhood, to carry a heavy sense of responsibility for the pain they might subconsciously feel they caused their adult caregivers. While the adults were possibly ill-equipped to deal with this, the inner child, even in adulthood, tends to carry a sense of guilt for it, often surpassing the awareness of their own pain.

As nonsensical as it may sound, the distress of a parent, often the very person whose approval was a battle to win in the first place, can register as the greater wound. It is in that collapsed reality, that the child who ‘was hurt’ and the adult who ‘causes hurt’ become one and the same.

(Read that again.)

And so, as far as the more uncomfortably dark questions go, where does that leave the child who was never given the protection they were entitled to?

They are abandoned, frozen, forgotten and buried in the hallway of a past, and eventually morph into the shadow that lurks in the background throughout the trajectory of adult life until they are seen, heard and held. Unacknowledged and without due recognition, but not forgotten. Ignored, but not invisible, and certainly not unfelt.

“Until you make the unconscious conscious, it will direct your life and you will call it fate.”

C.G. Jung

So what does that child do now? More often than not, the only thing it feels capable of: destroy.

Why this matters to me

The question that comes to me at this point is how any of this involves me, and why I care.

Apart from the fact that I generally care about the state of the world as it is today (call me a fool), my own ‘healing’ (for lack of a better term) is intertwined, for better or for worse, with many stories like this one. Many of these are not even direct parts of my own trajectory, but of the trajectories of loved ones, close friends, colleagues, ex-lovers and even collaborators. I am an artist. We don’t work without going deep into these rabbit holes. Everything we express revolves around the subconscious, IMHO.

Moreover (and this might feel like a segue but really isn’t), at a stage of life where the mortality of the previous generation makes itself more apparent, these threads tend to show up in my life in one form or another, and so do the people who were part of my earliest chapters. And I’ll go out on a limb and say that it is impossible to ignore that I might not be the only one out here dealing with this.

It is imperative to say here that, though subtle, the difference between caring and intruding is a clear one. Now personally, I have no intention of intruding on anyone’s life. Inversely, and probably more pertinently, I have no space in my own life for people who do not understand or respect boundaries either. The pull towards a kind of trauma bonding and the like, a somewhat nostalgic tribute to the past, is a common one. But common does not necessarily mean natural, or healthy, and left unexamined it turns into something else. So that’s not what interests me.

What does is art. And where I come from, art is and always will be about healing. The fact that it is created to transcend time and space is, again, something I fail to see as mere coincidence in this context.

Endings, and how we arrive at them

People going their separate ways under difficult circumstances is not just common but often healthy. I open this paragraph with that line because the bulk of the wake-up calls I listed earlier can broadly be summarised in these words. Departure. Goodbyes.

And without wanting to be tone-deaf to cultural contexts that might beg to differ on this take (not everyone will agree with the framing I am going with here), ‘culture’, the broad umbrella under which the arts seem to have been given their primary abode, does not transcend psychology. It can influence and inform it, but it cannot bypass it, let alone neurobiology.

How an ending happens, at whatever stage of our lives, tells us something. It is vital information.

When an ending comes about through the betrayal of those closest to us, whether it is a partnership, a band, a friendship, a working relationship or a family tie, it rarely comes out of nowhere. More often than not, the very patterns described above have been at work long before the final act: the ‘not enough’ voice growing louder, the pull towards familiar danger, the survival skills still running in the background.

That is not something to be judged, resented or belittled, even though it is human to do so.

But it is certainly not something to be ignored either. Our careers, finances and relationships: none of these exist without our perception of what they are supposed to be, and they are hence by no means immune to the aforementioned internal dialogue that tends to be brushed under the carpet as a default coping mechanism.

The presence of the shadow self, and the role it may play in the way a sequence of events unfolds, deserves attention. Whether it is indeed absent is a conclusion only a mindful, compassionate, non-escalating but thorough enquiry can actually confirm.

The dream job, partner, body and/or business is not a precursor to our internal state of equanimity. It’s the other way round. It’s stunning how the narrative has been flipped in most social discourse.

Identity: Who are we now?

Some connections span decades. Still being present in each other’s lives a quarter of a century later raises a question worth sitting with:

Who are we now?

In my world, being the same person I was five (let alone twenty-five) years ago would be missing the point completely. For others, the clarity needed to even take a stand on that question may not be there yet. Needless to say, all of that is a very individual journey, to be arrived at in our own time.

But unexamined patterns rarely announce themselves. What they tend to do instead is show up in small, deniable ways. A gesture of positioning here, an assumption about who someone is or where they belong there. Unsolicited conclusions here. A judgy comment disguised as friendly advice there. Signs like these can point to very clear conclusions once the patterns are clear to our minds, and yet they are also very easy to turn back on the person who names them, who is then labelled ‘overly sensitive’ or ‘insidious’. It can be tough to identify where the absolute line lies. This is why many of the resources humankind has historically relied upon for guidance on these conundrums are failing us today. The degree of personal responsibility involved in contributing to society as a collective does not get any easier, even if the simplicity of it remains timeless, as many ancient scriptures from all over the planet stand testimony to.

But some things are absolute. Your identity is not defined by anyone else’s history. Who you were two and a half decades ago is not someone else’s story to tell. And as far as my personal decisions are concerned, there is no space in my life for people who are unwilling to address their need to dominate these narratives, while refusing to acknowledge the unhealed wounds within themselves that keep leading them to hurt others.

To reiterate, I state that POV with the same compassion I referred to earlier.

What this asks of us

Regardless of whether you work in a creative field, you may recognise some of this in more familiar clothing. Perhaps it is the voice that questions your adequacy until a gatekeeper approves, or the way some of us only feel fully alive in chaos and last-minute deadlines, in volatile relationships and collaborations, because calm is unfamiliar and registers as a threat. Perhaps it is finding ourselves in the same difficult room years later, with the same difficult person wearing a fresh set of clothes, and calling it ‘fate’.

Blame has very little to offer here, whether aimed at ourselves or anyone else.

What helps is honesty about which of our skills were built for survival and are still running long after the threat has passed.

The child who adapted did what they had to do with whatever limited means they had. The adult now has the one thing that child never did: agency. And with it comes the choice to walk back down that hallway, find the parts of us that were left frozen, and finally offer them what they were owed all along, to be seen, heard and held.

Which brings me back to where this began. One person’s need to assert dominance, in whichever form it may manifest, is not someone else’s burden to bear.

Our unhealed wounds, however, are ours to tend, and the compassion I have asked for throughout this piece means very little until we can offer it to the child we once were. Once that work begins, what we used to call fate starts to look a great deal more like choice.


Join my free training. 


Artist Mindmap 2.0 is a reimagined 6-day email mini-course designed for serious, sensitive, and soulful artists who want more than 
surface-level hacks. 



0 Comments

Leave a Comment